“Survey says” looks at various rankings and scorecards judging geographic locations while noting these grades are best seen as a mix of artful interpretation and data.
Buzz: California’s housing costs – compared with other states – were at a seven-year low in 2022.
Source: My trusty spreadsheet looked at a curious cost-of-living yardstick – the federal government’s annual “price parity” report that puts key consumer expenses into a national perspective between the 50 states and the District of Columbia. We focused on the recently released data for 2002 and compared those stats with the last time California had a better housing cost number (2015).
Topline
California housing costs ran 60% above the US norm in 2022, by this math. That’s the smallest premium since 2015’s 58%.
So you see, I’m not saying the cost of putting a roof over your head in California has become any bargain. I’m only highlighting a sliver of calm in California’s affordability mess.
Golden State housing expenses still rank second-priciest in the US. Only DC was higher by this measurement, at 77% above average. New Jersey was No. 3 at 36%.
Now, if you’re looking for a housing-cost utopia, try West Virginia (46% below average), Arkansas (44% below) or Mississippi (43% below).
Details
The report highlights how some of the nation’s fast-growth economies are now suffering from what were once seen as exclusively coastal challenges: soaring housing costs.
California’s relative housing costs are up by 2 percentage points in seven years – but that’s only the No. 17 gain among the states. Ponder the bigger jumps since 2015.
Idaho is up 13.5 points, though its housing is still 12% cheaper than the US average. Nevada rose 13 points to become 12% above average. Arizona increased 12.5 points to 6% above average. Those are some of the nation’s fastest-growing economies – and common destinations for relocating Golden Staters.
And California’s arch-rivals? Florida was No. 7 with a 7-point jump to 16% above average. Texas was No. 14, up 3 points to 3% below average.
Yes, housing in some states got relatively much cheaper. Costs in Hawaii were off 22 percentage points but were still 32% above average. Alaska fell 18 points to 3% below average. And Connecticut was off 13 points to 19% above average.
Caveats
Related Articles
See the new California laws looking to boost affordable home construction
Stocks up 25% in 2023 vs. 5% gains for homes. Why the gap?
Construction start for San Jose housing tower is a ‘few months’ away: developer
Downtown San Jose store may become pet hotel, pet daycare, retail site
Conversion of San Jose tower from offices to homes starts to emerge
California’s overall cost of living remains lofty, by this math: It’s second-highest at 12% above average behind only DC’s 13%. Hawaii’s No. 3 at 11%.
The bargains were found in Arkansas and Mississippi where such costs were 13% less than the typical state. Texas was No. 23 at 2% below average, while Florida was No. 14 at 2% above average.
California’s overall cost-of-living premium rose over seven years – up 1.8 percentage points, the ninth-biggest gain.
Why did the price of California life rise despite the housing improvement? Blame utilities!
Those California costs were fourth-highest nationally, 47% above average in 2022, topped by only Hawaii at 101%, Massachusetts at 51% and New Hampshire at 48%.
The lows were in Idaho, at 34% below average, and Utah at 29% below. Texas was No. 29 at 11% below and Florida was No. 20 at 6% below.
Worse, utility bills soared in the Golden State. The California utility premium jumped by 18 percentage points over seven years, the No. 3 increase among the states.
Bottom line
Why do folks leave California?
Well, ponder the five states that got the most ex-Californians in 2022 and their cost-of-living advantage, according to the price parity equation …
Texas: A relocation would save a Californian 39% on housing and 13% overall.
Arizona: Saves 34% on housing and 11% overall.
Florida: Saves 27% on housing and 9% overall.
Washington: Saves 20% on housing and 2% overall.
Nevada: Saves 30% on housing and 14% overall.
Jonathan Lansner is the business columnist for the Southern California News Group. He can be reached at [email protected]